Victoria urges Naomi to keep Sarah inside Collinwood, but Sarah sees Barnabas and follows him.

Barnabas bites Ruby Tate at the Collinsport docks. He returns to the mausoleum with a bloodied face.

A rain-drenched Sarah falls desperately ill. Ben helps Barnabas to secretly visit her at Collinwood.

Guilt-ridden over Sarah’s death, Barnabas tries to persuade Ben to drive a stake through his heart.

Angelique’s ghost taunts Ben, telling him that the curse she placed on Barnabas must continue for eternity.

Josette is drawn to secretly meet with Barnabas, who tries to resist baring his fangs to bite her.

Barnabas reluctantly informs Josette they must stay apart forever. Suki Forbes arrives in Collinsport.

Suki is introduced as Nathan’s sister, even though she is his wife. Barnabas and Josette meet for a final embrace.

Noticing Josette’s strange behavior, Natalie pleads with Victoria to break the apparent spell on Josette.

Joshua goes to the tomb where he buried Barnabas and discovers that his coffin is now empty.

Suki discovers what Barnabas is and divulges his secret to Nathan before she dies.

Joshua and Naomi fear Josette will die the next day as recorded in the Collins family history book.

Josette is beckoned by Angelique to Widows’ Hill, where she sees a terrifying vision of herself.

Millicent sees Barnabas in the graveyard. She informs Joshua that Barnabas ran away from her.

Reverend Trask calls upon Abigail to testify against Victoria as her witchcraft trial begins at the courthouse.

Joshua goes to the mausoleum and finds that the coffin now contains the body of Barnabas.

Peter realizes he must hide the Collins family history book, fearing it will be used against Victoria at her trial.

Using his occult powers, Barnabas raises Josette from the dead but he is horrified at her disfigured face.

Abigail investigates the Old House, unaware that Barnabas has moved his coffin into the basement.

Disturbed by Trask’s interrogation of him, Daniel runs outside and discovers the dead body of Abigail.

Hoping to save Victoria from a guilty verdict, Peter tries to persuade Nathan to testify on her behalf.

After Nathan commits perjury for him on the witness stand, Trask convinces Joshua to forgive Nathan.

At the trial, Ben reveals that Angelique is a witch, but she soon materializes and condemns Victoria.

As a final effort to save her, Peter urges Victoria to tell the truth about herself, despite the risk.

Victoria testifies in court. A guilty verdict is announced and she is sentenced to be hanged as a witch.

Barnabas learns of Victoria’s predicament and vows to avenge the unjust decision against her.

While attacking Maude Browning, a waterfront streetwalker, Barnabas accidentally drops his cane.

After Barnabas kills Maude, Trask is shocked to find her dead body lying in his bed.

Nathan discovers Maude’s body and promises to help Trask dispose of it in return for Trask’s help.

Barnabas lures Trask to the basement of the Old House and seals him up behind a brick wall.

Carrying Barnabas’ cane, Noah Gifford disguises himself and feigns an attack against Millicent.

Nathan pretends to rescue Millicent, who believes it was Barnabas who attacked her.

At Nathan’s urging, Joshua goes to the Old House and is devastated to witness Barnabas rising from his coffin.

Barnabas tells Joshua he is the Collinsport Strangler. In pity, Joshua shoots his son through the heart.

Joshua realizes the truth about Barnabas and insists he be hidden in the tower room at Collinwood.

Nathan decides to drive Millicent insane, but then he notices that she sees lights in the tower room.

Nathan sends Millicent to the tower room where she discovers Barnabas. He sinks his fangs into her neck.

Bathia Mapes, summoned from the supernatural, attempts to lift the curse from Barnabas.

In the Old House, Bathia’s spell is interrupted by a visit from Naomi. Bathia is consumed by flames.

Threatening the jailer with a gun, Peter leads Victoria from her cell, but she is wounded as she escapes.